Friend or Friendly? How to Tell Who’s Really in Your Corner
- Sep 21
- 11 min read
My daughter asked me to explain the signs that show someone is a true friend and when it is appropriate to reciprocate friendship. The numerous times I got hurt in relationships have made me consider taking a friend or friendly course in how to establish friendship with another person. The question made me wonder if I truly understand the answer to this question. The way friendship appears to others does not always match its true nature. People who display wide smiles and ask about your children and share your social media content will disappear when your life becomes complicated or quiet. People who rarely talk to you will bring food and maintain silence when you require their presence the most.
I used to consider every person I met as my friend. Sort of like when Oprah had her car giveaway event, I would say "you are my friend" multiple times to anyone who give me the time of day. I used the word "friend" as if it were confetti pieces at a festive parade. I hold affection for all people while seeking their positive feelings in return. The term "friend" has turned against me during specific situations. People revealed their authentic nature to me, but I chose to ignore it until they delivered a massive blow of disappointment. The bricks that hit me were extremely painful.
I observed my young children as they established playground alliances through social dynamics that included membership rules and shifting friendships. People in adulthood maintain similar behaviors to children although they present themselves differently through professional conduct and social etiquette and workplace relationships.
Authentic friendships display indicators which help you distinguish them from brief encounters and shallow relationships. Not just friendly. Not just familiar. A genuine friend stays aware of your existence while giving you space and shows no reaction to your spontaneous actions. A genuine friend embraces your entire being with all your strange actions and deep feelings and honest words without treating them as passing phases or problems. The friendships maintain their genuine nature because they do not require fake performances.
This blog aims to identify the fundamental distinction between these relationships. I want to recognize the people who truly matter. The real people in your life deserve your recognition and you should remember that not everyone qualifies for this special status.
A friendship represents a particular bond between two people who share affection while trusting each other and being loyal to one another and providing emotional backing. People in friendships create value for each other through shared activities and common interests while offering support during all life experiences. A genuine friendship develops through honest communication and mutual respect which creates a strong connection that lets people express their true nature.
Red Flags: When It’s Not Friendship, Just Familiarity
The similarity between familiarity and friendship becomes so strong that you might only recognize the difference through painful experiences. The familiarity of daily routines exists without the protective bond of genuine friendship. The signs indicate that your current relationship with someone might be based on habit rather than genuine friendship.
The appearance of friendship often results from people spending time together while pretending to show concern for each other. Their disinterest in your personal development becomes evident when they choose to leave instead of supporting your growth. The person you used to has transformed into a reflection that shows only their preferred aspects of yourself.
Their public displays of support through loud cheering turn into complete silence when you need their help the most. You constantly initiate contact with this person yet their absence would become evident if you stopped reaching out. Their control over your vulnerability allows them to use your trusted information against you through gossip or manipulation.
Your happiness diminishes whenever you spend time with this person. Their reactions to your achievements consist of mocking comments and complete silence and hidden attempts to outdo you. They view your established limits as attacks against them and disregard your boundaries by pushing forward without permission. These aren't just red flags.
They’re reminders to protect your peace and redefine what friendship truly means.
Green Lights: Signs You’ve Found a Real One
A true friendship exists through consistent support rather than through loud displays. The presence of such friendship allows you to feel understood without needing to show off because it values your silence. They appear at times when it is difficult to reach them because they will help you with both the celebration and the cleanup process. Your personal development brings them joy instead of causing them concern.
The person stays by your side as you grow because they adapt their own development to match yours. They keep track of unimportant details because these details hold special value for you. You experience complete emotional security when spending time with this person because you can express yourself authentically while receiving gentle care. The establishment of boundaries creates no barriers because they receive proper respect without any form of pressure or resistance. They express their genuine happiness for your joy through loud celebrations while avoiding any need for personal attention.
That’s not just friendship. That’s home.
The Gray Zone: Where Friendship Gets Foggy
Not every relationship fits neatly into “friend” or “not friend.” Some people live in the in-between—what I call the gray zone. They’re not toxic, but they’re not nourishing. They’re not enemies, but they’re not allies.
They’re… just there.
Traits of Gray Zone People:
The surface appearance of friendship through smiling and laughing and friendly words hides the absence of genuine care that real friendships need. These individuals maintain a kind demeanor, but their support remains unreliable. They appear during enjoyable times but disappear when challenges become more difficult. Their words seem perfect, yet you experience complete emotional isolation when you are with them. You avoid revealing your true self because you doubt, they will treat your openness with respect.
These people ask you to join their events, but they never try to understand your actual state of mind. They exist in your social network, but they do not participate in your recovery process. The sense of comfort from knowing someone does not replace the experience of being fully supported by them. True friendship requires more than physical presence because it demands emotional connection.
Navigating the Gray:
The gray zone isn’t a failure—it’s a filter. It helps you assess who belongs where in your life. Not everyone deserves full access. Some people are meant for the outer rings, not the inner sanctum.
You might say:
“I don’t need to cut you off. I just need to reposition you.”
This is where your boundary-setting comes in. You can do the following:
• Reframe relationships without guilt.
• Release the pressure to make every connection deep.
• Embrace JOMO—the Joy of Missing Out on shallow friendships.
I have friends who show up without being asked—no hesitation, no conditions. They pop up when it matters, and I never have to wonder where I stand with them. And then there are “friends” who seem to have endless support for our mutuals, but somehow never manage to hit the like button on anything I share. How does that make me feel? It hurts. It stings in a quiet way. But I’ve learned to move past it. I’ve learned that not everyone who’s around is truly with you—and that’s okay. My energy now goes where it’s reciprocated.
Seasonal, Situational, and Surface-Level: Not All Connections Are Meant to Be Deep
Our society promotes instant relationships because we believe that meaningful connections through laughter and shared vulnerability will lead to eternal friendships. The special moments we experience with others remain valuable even though they do not need to develop into lasting friendships. My problem is I want all relationships to blossom into lasing friendships. Again, I’m learning it’s ok to not have that always happen.
Some individuals exist to play supporting roles in our lives rather than becoming our lifelong companions. People enter our lives during important moments such as transitions and celebrations and times of crisis and creative breakthroughs. Their presence brings valuable insights and friendship and happiness, yet their involvement remains limited to a particular time frame. The connection remains authentic even though its duration is limited. The connection exists for a particular reason which defines its duration. And for me, these moments are unforgetting.
Light connections do not indicate superficial relationships. Acquaintances who bring laughter to the farmer's market and colleagues who enhance meetings and fellow parents who exchange understanding glances at pickup time all contribute value to our lives. These casual interactions provide us with essential nourishment through their small but significant contributions.
People experience excessive stress because they believe friendships need to persist indefinitely. People experience feelings of shame when their friendships end, and they start to question their capacity to build lasting relationships. That is me, I am those people.
The natural process of relationship release follows its own timeline which demands that we let go of specific bonds. Some relationships serve their purpose by disappearing instead of developing into deeper connections.
Seasonal People:
They enter during a particular chapter of your life—college, a job, a parenting phase—and feel like soulmates in the moment. But when the season shifts, so does the connection.
• They were perfect for that version of you.
• You shared something real, but time moved on.
• Letting go doesn’t mean betrayal—it means honoring the role they played.
The friends I had from previous work environments who seemed destined to become lifelong companions did not stay connected after I or they transitioned to different jobs. My college friends who studied with me through all classes and spent time together during school hours and weekends disappeared after graduation. The people who supported me through my parents' death have since disappeared from my life. They provided essential support during my challenging times and assisted me in understanding what occurred. The moment I regained stability they vanished from my life.
The relationship ended without any negative feelings between us since we maintain positive feelings toward each other. Our connection faded away without any specific reason. They existed to support me during that particular time, but their purpose ended when that period passed.
The passage of time created distance between us but during that specific time they became essential to both of us.
Situational People:
These are the ones you bond with through shared organization: coworkers, fellow vendors, PTA parents. You laugh, collaborate, even vent—but the connection rarely leaves the context.
• They’re great in the group chat, but not in your grief.
• You trust them with tasks, not your heart.
• It’s okay to keep it light and functional.
Surface-Level People:
They’re friendly, familiar, and even fun—but you sense a limit. They don’t ask deeper questions. They don’t hold space. They’re safe, but they’re not nourishing either.
• You don’t owe them intimacy.
• You can enjoy their presence without inviting them into your process.
• Not every smile is an invitation.
Circle Placement: Who Gets Access to Your Inner World?
Think of your relationships like concentric circles:
Circle Who Belongs: Their Access Level
Inner Circle: Your real ones—safe, reciprocal, deeply invested Full access: emotions, truth, trust.
Middle Circle: Good people—kind, consistent, but not fully aligned Selective access: shared joy, light support.
Outer Circle: Acquaintances, seasonal/situational folks, polite connections Limited access: updates, small talk
You get to decide who moves closer and who stays further out. And you can reposition people without drama, guilt, or explanation. Which I have. There have been friends who were apart of my inn circle who have moved to the outer circle. And then there were friends who were in the outer circle and have been moved to the middle circle. It depends on yours and that person comfort level around each other. How much do you trust each other?
“I’m not cutting you off. I’m just adjusting your seat”, is how I put it.
When my daughter asked me about identifying a friend, I provided her with this straightforward test to determine if she had a genuine friendship that went beyond casual socializing. I told her to imagine she was at the mall with her friend. Just the two of them. I asked her would she feel comfortable spending time by herself with this person? Would she feel comfortable during a meal with this person? If the answer was no to these questions, then it could be that that person is more of an acquaintance.
You can share laughter with this person during group activities, yet you would not reveal your inner self to them. You can share your deepest thoughts with them, but they excel at creating light-hearted moments during casual social interactions.
Every relationship does not need to be intense. The distinction between different types of relationships becomes clearer through this framework. This framework enables you to defend your inner peace while respecting your boundaries to build relationships based on mutual connection rather than forced duty.
From Chasing to Curating: A Personal Shift
I used to believe that if someone smiled at me or showed me any attention, that meant they were my friend. I used to think that anyone who spent time with me and showed kindness was someone I could trust. I granted complete access to people who did not deserve it because I believed being included would automatically create deep bonds. The experience of time taught me that people wanting your company does not mean they value you. People who receive your affection do not necessarily hold you in their hearts.
The discovery that someone does not consider you a friend creates a soft yet painful sensation. But there’s also deep relief. The act of stopping your pursuit for connection allows you to build meaningful relationships with others. You will discover the people who listen without criticism and who honor your limits and who find happiness in your success without taking any part of it.
“I used to chase connection. Now I curate it.”
The entire world has undergone a complete transformation because of this change. The change has enabled me to defend my inner peace while respecting my energy levels and establishing relationships based on mutual support instead of achievement.
The lesson I learned about authentic friendship shows that true companionship exists through steady presence rather than high spirited behavior. The presence of imperfections does not diminish the value of friendship because it remains authentic.
You are not showing coldness to others during this time of change and transition. You are being clear. Clarity serves as a form of self-care which benefits both your own well-being and the people around you.
Reclaiming Your Front Row
Friendship exists beyond the presence of people because it requires those who remain by your side while actively listening to your growth. Your inner world remains sacred while you navigate through the gray areas and temporary relationships and superficial greetings. Not everyone gets a backstage pass.
If the answer is no, you’re allowed to rearrange the chairs. With love. With clarity. With zero guilt. Because curating your circle isn’t cruelty—it’s care.
So, to answer my daughter’s question, the process of determining if someone is your genuine friend and if you want them as a friend requires paying attention to your physical sensations.
Your body will guide you to understand the situation. Your physical state changes after spending time with this person. Your presence in their company makes you feel either powerful or weak. The atmosphere around you becomes either protective or invasive. You experience genuine laughter when you are with them, or you maintain constant alertness.
True friendship creates a sensation of deep relaxation in your body. The relationship maintains its flaws but delivers authentic interactions. A true friend observes your imperfect center without showing any sign of discomfort. The person supports your victories through applause but also remains present during your moments of silence.
The desire for someone to become your friend represents a wonderful aspiration. That is not a binding agreement. You maintain the right to seek connection while making decisions that lead to inner peace. You have permission to view someone with respect while maintaining control over your life force.
You possess the right to express your refusal through statements like "Not yet" or "Not this" or "Not anymore."
The quality of friendship depends on the person who maintains their connection with you rather than the number of people who show up.
Keep building your collection of meaningful relationships while maintaining your breathwork practice and select relationships that support your personal development.
You don’t owe anyone closeness. You owe yourself peace.
So, take a breath. Look around. And ask yourself:
“Who’s in my front row—and do they deserve the seat?”
🌈 P.S. Did you know?
When I’m not writing about friendship and emotional safety, I’m crafting stories for children that celebrate curiosity, courage, and connection. If you’re a parent, educator, or just someone who loves imaginative storytelling, I’d love for you to explore my children’s books.
Comments